NFBC Message Boards

Any opinion on which one you'd rather have moving forward? Garza's looked pretty good but Shields is on a better team and should end up with more wins...although, Garza may get traded to a contender before the trade deadline.

I like Shields better. Garza may get more Ks, but I think Shields is the better pitcher. He also will get more wins, although that's not Garza's fault. Of course, Garza looked pretty good yesterday ....

Shields is more volatile and has the tougher schedule. I'd take Garza and expect better ratios with comparable Ks and Ws.