NFBC Message Boards

Looking at the top 60 in ADP and 1/2 of them are complete washouts or probably going to be washouts, especially relative to where they were drafted and what owners needed from them. Seems slots 30-60 are really stinking it up this year.

Any of these under achievers have a chance of turning it around?

Just my opinion though...

#1 Miguel Cabrera (3B, Det)
#2 Mike Trout (CF, LAA)
#3 Ryan Braun (LF, Mil)
#4 Robinson Cano (2B, NYY)
#5 Matt Kemp (CF, LAD) BUST
#6 Andrew McCutchen (CF, Pit)
#7 Joey Votto (1B, Cin)
#8 Albert Pujols (1B, LAA) Jury's OUT
#9 Carlos Gonzalez (LF, Col)
#10 Prince Fielder (1B, Det)
#11 Troy Tulowitzki (SS, Col)
#12 Giancarlo Stanton (RF, Mia) BUST
#13 Justin Verlander (SP, Det)
#14 Stephen Strasburg (SP Jury's OUT
#15 Clayton Kershaw (SP, LAD)
#16 Josh Hamilton (RF, LAA) BUST
#17 Buster Posey (C, SF)
#18 Jose Bautista (RF, Tor)
#19 Justin Upton (LF, Atl)
#20 Bryce Harper (LF, Was)
#21 Evan Longoria (3B, TB)
#22 Jose Reyes (SS, Tor) BUST
#23 Adrian Beltre (3B, Tex)
#24 Jason Heyward (RF, Atl) BUST
#25 Dustin Pedroia (2B, Bos)
#26 David Wright (3B, NYM)
#27 David Price (SP, TB) Jury's OUT- Leaning BUST
#28 Edwin Encarnacion (1B, Tor)
#29 Adam Jones (CF, Bal)
#30 Ian Kinsler (2B, Tex) Jury's OUT
#31 Adrian Gonzalez (1B, LAD) Jury's OUT
#32 Yoenis Cespedes (CF, Oak) Jury's OUT- Leaning BUST
#33 Ryan Zimmerman (3B, Was) Jury's OUT
#34 Starlin Castro (SS, ChC) Jury's OUT- Leaning BUST
#35 Jacoby Ellsbury (CF, Bos) Jury's OUT- Leaning BUST
#36 Felix Hernandez (SP, Sea)
#37 Cole Hamels (SP, Phi) BUST
#38 Jay Bruce (RF, Cin) Jury's OUT
#39 B.J. Upton (CF, Atl) BUST
#40 Matt Cain (SP, SF) Jury's OUT
#41 Paul Goldschmidt (1B, Ari)
#42 Billy Butler (DH, KC) BUST
#43 Ian Desmond (SS, Was) Jury's OUT
#44 Cliff Lee (SP, Phi) Jury's OUT
#45 Matt Holliday (LF, StL)
#46 Craig Kimbrel (MR, Atl)
#47 Allen Craig (1B, StL)
#48 Ben Zobrist (2B, TB) Jury's OUT
#49 Aramis Ramirez (3B, Mil) Jury's OUT
#50 Gio Gonzalez (SP, Was) Jury's OUT
#51 Yu Darvish (SP, Tex)
#52 Jered Weaver (SP, LAA) Jury's OUT
#53 Joe Mauer (C, Min)
#54 Madison Bumgarner (SP, SF)
#55 Aaron Hill (2B, Ari) BUST
#56 Jason Kipnis (2B, Cle) Jury's OUT
#57 Jimmy Rollins (SS, Phi) BUST
#58 Adam Wainwright (SP, StL)
#59 Zack Greinke (SP, LAD) Jury's OUT
#60 Brandon Phillips (2B, Cin)

Cliff Lee has been awful.

Hells Satans wrote:Cliff Lee has been awful.

6-2 with a 2.34 ERA - putrid

Outlaw wrote:Looking at the top 60 in ADP and 1/2 of them are complete washouts or probably going to be washouts, especially relative to where they were drafted and what owners needed from them. Seems slots 30-60 are really stinking it up this year.

Any of these under achievers have a chance of turning it around?

Just my opinion though...

#1 Miguel Cabrera (3B, Det)
#2 Mike Trout (CF, LAA)
#3 Ryan Braun (LF, Mil)
#4 Robinson Cano (2B, NYY)
#5 Matt Kemp (CF, LAD) BUST
#6 Andrew McCutchen (CF, Pit)
#7 Joey Votto (1B, Cin)
#8 Albert Pujols (1B, LAA) Jury's OUT
#9 Carlos Gonzalez (LF, Col)
#10 Prince Fielder (1B, Det)
#11 Troy Tulowitzki (SS, Col)
#12 Giancarlo Stanton (RF, Mia) BUST
#13 Justin Verlander (SP, Det)
#14 Stephen Strasburg (SP Jury's OUT
#15 Clayton Kershaw (SP, LAD)
#16 Josh Hamilton (RF, LAA) BUST
#17 Buster Posey (C, SF)
#18 Jose Bautista (RF, Tor)
#19 Justin Upton (LF, Atl)
#20 Bryce Harper (LF, Was)
#21 Evan Longoria (3B, TB)
#22 Jose Reyes (SS, Tor) BUST
#23 Adrian Beltre (3B, Tex)
#24 Jason Heyward (RF, Atl) BUST
#25 Dustin Pedroia (2B, Bos)
#26 David Wright (3B, NYM)
#27 David Price (SP, TB) Jury's OUT- Leaning BUST
#28 Edwin Encarnacion (1B, Tor)
#29 Adam Jones (CF, Bal)
#30 Ian Kinsler (2B, Tex) Jury's OUT
#31 Adrian Gonzalez (1B, LAD) Jury's OUT
#32 Yoenis Cespedes (CF, Oak) Jury's OUT- Leaning BUST
#33 Ryan Zimmerman (3B, Was) Jury's OUT
#34 Starlin Castro (SS, ChC) Jury's OUT- Leaning BUST
#35 Jacoby Ellsbury (CF, Bos) Jury's OUT- Leaning BUST
#36 Felix Hernandez (SP, Sea)
#37 Cole Hamels (SP, Phi) BUST
#38 Jay Bruce (RF, Cin) Jury's OUT
#39 B.J. Upton (CF, Atl) BUST
#40 Matt Cain (SP, SF) Jury's OUT
#41 Paul Goldschmidt (1B, Ari)
#42 Billy Butler (DH, KC) BUST
#43 Ian Desmond (SS, Was) Jury's OUT
#44 Cliff Lee (SP, Phi) Jury's OUT
#45 Matt Holliday (LF, StL)
#46 Craig Kimbrel (MR, Atl)
#47 Allen Craig (1B, StL)
#48 Ben Zobrist (2B, TB) Jury's OUT
#49 Aramis Ramirez (3B, Mil) Jury's OUT
#50 Gio Gonzalez (SP, Was) Jury's OUT
#51 Yu Darvish (SP, Tex)
#52 Jered Weaver (SP, LAA) Jury's OUT
#53 Joe Mauer (C, Min)
#54 Madison Bumgarner (SP, SF)
#55 Aaron Hill (2B, Ari) BUST
#56 Jason Kipnis (2B, Cle) Jury's OUT
#57 Jimmy Rollins (SS, Phi) BUST
#58 Adam Wainwright (SP, StL)
#59 Zack Greinke (SP, LAD) Jury's OUT
#60 Brandon Phillips (2B, Cin)

Actually, I think we collectively did pretty well in the first two rounds (Top 30). Only five clear busts out of 30 by your count, and some are or may be injury related. After Round 2, however, things get much more shaky.

Every now and then, if I really want to torture myself, I'll go back and look at the original draft boards for some of my leagues. Yep, that was some pick grabbing Eric Hosmer ahead of Chris Davis.

Mike

If unlucky means "Bust", I will agree on Hamels. One win despite giving up three earned runs or less in eight of his last nine games, 91.3% strike out rate, less than a hit per IP, hasn't given up a HR on the road this year yet. First two games were brutal but has a 3.24 ERA and a 1.131 WHIP since.

Kind of this year's version of Cliff Lee from last year.

If the jury is out on Ellsbury then I'd have to say the jury is out on McCutcheon too.

Playing better now but still a power shortage for someone in the top 10 ADP.

Keeping my fingers crossed McCutch will have a hot streak and get back to 2012 power levels soon.

Deadheadz wrote:If the jury is out on Ellsbury then I'd have to say the jury is out on McCutcheon too.

Playing better now but still a power shortage for someone in the top 10 ADP.

Keeping my fingers crossed McCutch will have a hot streak and get back to 2012 power levels soon.

I thought about sending him to the jury...

Edwards Kings wrote:If unlucky means "Bust", I will agree on Hamels. One win despite giving up three earned runs or less in eight of his last nine games, 91.3% strike out rate, less than a hit per IP, hasn't given up a HR on the road this year yet. First two games were brutal but has a 3.24 ERA and a 1.131 WHIP since.

Kind of this year's version of Cliff Lee from last year.

Come again?

DOUGHBOYS wrote:

Edwards Kings wrote:If unlucky means "Bust", I will agree on Hamels. One win despite giving up three earned runs or less in eight of his last nine games, 91.3% strike out rate, less than a hit per IP, hasn't given up a HR on the road this year yet. First two games were brutal but has a 3.24 ERA and a 1.131 WHIP since.

Kind of this year's version of Cliff Lee from last year.

Come again?

oops...me and my big mouth...