NFBC Message Boards

We will allow these players to have a DL designation next to them this week as they were deemed out for the season this week:



Chris Duncan

Chad Tracy

Danys Baez

Chris Sampson

Neal Musser



There won't be a DL designation next to them, but you will be allowed to move them from your starting lineup to your reserve roster and replace them with a reserve player as long as your team meets the position eligibility requirements. Good luck all.

???



I'm assuming this isn't the entire list. There could be additions for this week, correct? Midnight on Thursday is that date/time constraint, correct, just like any other week.

Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

???



I'm assuming this isn't the entire list. There could be additions for this week, correct? Midnight on Thursday is that date/time constraint, correct, just like any other week. Correct. These are the players we added this week to what was already added last week. We will add more tomorrow and send out another e-mail if needed. Guys like Jonathan Sanchez we're still waiting for more information on before adding anyone else to the list. We'll finalize this tomorrow and will post any additions here first and send out another e-mail if needed.

Don't be to quick on the trigger there Hoss. I see one of your boys from last week may be playing in a few days.

Kind of crazy to have a DL list update when there isn't even 15 days left in the season.

Originally posted by DOUGHBOYS:

Kind of crazy to have a DL list update when there isn't even 15 days left in the season. next week's will be even crazier!!!

Originally posted by Greg Ambrosius:

We will allow these players to have a DL designation next to them this week as they were deemed out for the season this week:



Chris Duncan

Chad Tracy

Danys Baez

Chris Sampson

Neal Musser



There won't be a DL designation next to them, but you will be allowed to move them from your starting lineup to your reserve roster and replace them with a reserve player as long as your team meets the position eligibility requirements. Good luck all. Greg,



I really don't like these lists. I think the only players who should be consider are players who get hurt during the current week(Monday thru Thursday). Players like Duncan, Baez,and Tracy have been hurt before this week. No owner should have them in their line-up. If they do, they failed on their end to do their homework.



September should be a month when the owner decide when it is time to move on from a player. If they do not sit a hurt player from the previous week, they shouldn't be rewarded because they hoped he would play.



[ September 19, 2007, 03:27 PM: Message edited by: CC's Desperados ]

James Shields has been "shut down" for the remainder of the season, does he go on the NFBC DL?

Originally posted by KJ Duke:

James Shields has been "shut down" for the remainder of the season, does he go on the NFBC DL? let me ask you this duke: if the devil rays "shut down" shields in the middle of the season, would he go on the DL?

Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

quote:Originally posted by KJ Duke:

James Shields has been "shut down" for the remainder of the season, does he go on the NFBC DL? let me ask you this duke: if the devil rays "shut down" shields in the middle of the season, would he go on the DL? [/QUOTE]Yes, because they wouldn't/couldn't hold open an active roster spot for him if wasn't going to pitch again.

Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

quote:Originally posted by KJ Duke:

James Shields has been "shut down" for the remainder of the season, does he go on the NFBC DL? let me ask you this duke: if the devil rays "shut down" shields in the middle of the season, would he go on the DL? [/QUOTE]Are you suggesting you want a roster exception for Shields? This will never happen because he is not HURT. A team decision not to pitch a player is a personal desicion.

Originally posted by CC's Desperados:

quote:Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

quote:Originally posted by KJ Duke:

James Shields has been "shut down" for the remainder of the season, does he go on the NFBC DL? let me ask you this duke: if the devil rays "shut down" shields in the middle of the season, would he go on the DL? [/QUOTE]Are you suggesting you want a roster exception for Shields? This will never happen because he is not HURT. A team decision not to pitch a player is a personal desicion. [/QUOTE]i'm not suggesting anything, you seem to be. i asked duke a question, because i didn't know how it would be handled by the devil rays

could shields be optioned to triple A?

Let me ask you this duke: Would the devil rays "shut down" shields in the middle of the season if he didn't need to go on the DL?

just an fyi - i don't think shields is eligible for the DL. i'm simply wondering how it would be handled if this happened at the end of august.

Originally posted by KJ Duke:

James Shields has been "shut down" for the remainder of the season, does he go on the NFBC DL? No. It's a management decision, not an injury.

Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

just an fyi - i don't think shields is eligible for the DL. i'm simply wondering how it would be handled if this happened at the end of august. Hopefully, teams don't shut down pitchers in the middle of the season because they are worried about the number of innings they've pitched. That's what is happening here.

greg: having been put through the grinder this year, i'd suggest that you drop the Sept DL rule next year. in some cases it can be too subjective, and i KNOW it's time consuming to administer this rule.

Originally posted by CC's Desperados:

quote:Originally posted by Greg Ambrosius:

We will allow these players to have a DL designation next to them this week as they were deemed out for the season this week:



Chris Duncan

Chad Tracy

Danys Baez

Chris Sampson

Neal Musser



There won't be a DL designation next to them, but you will be allowed to move them from your starting lineup to your reserve roster and replace them with a reserve player as long as your team meets the position eligibility requirements. Good luck all. Greg,



I really don't like these lists. I think the only players who should be consider are players who get hurt during the current week(Monday thru Thursday). Players like Duncan, Baez,and Tracy have been hurt before this week. No owner should have them in their line-up. If they do, they failed on their end to do their homework.



September should be a month when the owner decide when it is time to move on from a player. If they do not sit a hurt player from the previous week, they shouldn't be rewarded because they hoped he would play. [/QUOTE]It's not my job to make sure every owner is managing his/her team correctly, Shawn, just adhering to the rules. You might be surprised each week how many owners do replace a DL guy from their starting roster that they forgot about on Monday. It happens all season long and last week was no exception.

Originally posted by Greg Ambrosius:

quote:Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

just an fyi - i don't think shields is eligible for the DL. i'm simply wondering how it would be handled if this happened at the end of august. Hopefully, teams don't shut down pitchers in the middle of the season because they are worried about the number of innings they've pitched. That's what is happening here. [/QUOTE]i know the key word is "hopefully", but what if shields reached his innings cap in August. what would tampa do with him?



[ September 19, 2007, 05:11 PM: Message edited by: Gordon Gekko ]

Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

greg: having been put through the grinder this year, i'd suggest that you drop the Sept DL rule next year. in some cases it can be too subjective, and i KNOW it's time consuming to administer this rule. Thanks for the suggestion. I'll consider it. I understand the pluses and the minuses of it and yes it is tough to administer. But I can see how it works if I'm doing my job right. We'll see about 2008.

Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

quote:Originally posted by Greg Ambrosius:

quote:Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

just an fyi - i don't think shields is eligible for the DL. i'm simply wondering how it would be handled if this happened at the end of august. Hopefully, teams don't shut down pitchers in the middle of the season because they are worried about the number of innings they've pitched. That's what is happening here. [/QUOTE]i know the key word is "hopefully", but what if shields reached his innings cap in August. what would tampa do with him? [/QUOTE]I don't deal in hypotheticals. He's not hurt, just not playing.

Posted 09/19/2007 10:35 PM ET

"Bochy confirmed that left-hander Jonathan Sanchez, who strained his left oblique muscle Tuesday, won't pitch again this season."



****://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20070919&content_id=2218887&vkey=news_mlb&fext=.jsp&c_id=mlb&partnered=rss_mlb



Please add Sanchez to the DL List for this week. Thank you!



[ September 19, 2007, 10:48 PM: Message edited by: Gordon Gekko ]

If you were depending on Sanchez, you gotta be in big trouble anyway.

Originally posted by Richie:

If you were depending on Sanchez, you gotta be in big trouble anyway. Word