NFBC Message Boards

Which player has been the biggest disappointment to their owners? Which player STOLE their owner's fantasy entry money this season?



My pick: Jimmy Rollins

Josh Hamilton.

If you're not including injured or 50-game suspended players, then at this point from players chosen in the first 5 rds...



1. Ortiz

2. Rollins

3. BJ Upton

4. Berkman



On the flip side (first 5rds):



1. Mauer

2. V Mart

3. Adrian Gonzalez

Richard, you forgot Joe Reyes.



And, if his "issues" keep him out for an extended period, which I think they will , Joe Votto can't be far down that list either. Great start, but if that's all he gives, not worth the spot.

I know he's not a 1st rounder but a lot of people invested heavily in Chris Davis, who is now hitting .199 with his 0-3 with 3 k's tonight!

Three that come to mind that i thought people wherer way too high on Chris Davis , Jason motte and Nelson Cruz, only Cruz has panned out

TOP 25 BUM'S

1 REYES JUST HURT

2 SIZEMORE LOW BAVG AND HURT



3 ROLLINS FOOLED BY 2007 SEASON

4 HAMILTON CANT STAY HEALTHY

5 BERKMAN BAD 2ND HALF NUMBERS CARRY OVER

6 BJ UPTON NO POWER AND BAD BAVG

7 MANNY 50 GAME SUSPENTION

8 ARAMIS RAM HURT

9 QUENTIN HURT LOW BAVG

10 R MARTIN GOES WAY TOO HIGH

11 WEBB TO MANY INNINGS

12 McCANN 22 RBI'S

13 VLADDY DONE

14 FURCAL GOT OLD FAST

15 C DAVIS WANTED NO PARTOF HIM

16 SOTO SHOW ME TWICE

17 ORTIZ DIDNT SEE THIS

18 LIRIANO HE'S CRUSHED ME

19 UGGLA BAVG KILLER

20 DREW BAD START

21 LIDGE FROM PERFECT TO SUCK'S

22 TULO NOT MUCH

23 J BRUCE LOW BAVG NOT THIS SEASON

24 ATKINS HORRIBLE 2ND HALF NUMBER'S LAST YEAR

25 PERALTA NO POWER

I've got three from your list Eddie. Who has got more?

too soon to throw the book at Rollins. I don't have him in this league, but have had him over the past 3 years in a CBS league. Although he'll likely never match his full year run of 2007 (which arguably should be expected going into draft day), he does play to those numbers (pro-rated of course) consistently from August through end of the year.



Although you'll go through the first half of the season frustrated, he makes up for it and puts up numbers comparable to his MVP season when it counts.



Aug/Sept/Oct (2006 & 2008 Season Avg)

Runs = 40

HR = 8

RBI = 33

SB = 19

BA = .300



Aug/Sept/Oct (2007 Season)

Runs = 48

HR = 10

RBI = 29

SB = 22

BA = .297

JRoll 1, Ortiz 4, Drew 5, Uggla 6

Originally posted by eddiejag:

TOP 25 BUM'S

1 REYES JUST HURT

2 SIZEMORE LOW BAVG AND HURT



3 ROLLINS FOOLED BY 2007 SEASON

4 HAMILTON CANT STAY HEALTHY

5 BERKMAN BAD 2ND HALF NUMBERS CARRY OVER

6 BJ UPTON NO POWER AND BAD BAVG

7 MANNY 50 GAME SUSPENTION

8 ARAMIS RAM HURT

9 QUENTIN HURT LOW BAVG

10 R MARTIN GOES WAY TOO HIGH

11 WEBB TO MANY INNINGS

12 McCANN 22 RBI'S

13 VLADDY DONE

14 FURCAL GOT OLD FAST

15 C DAVIS WANTED NO PARTOF HIM

16 SOTO SHOW ME TWICE

17 ORTIZ DIDNT SEE THIS

18 LIRIANO HE'S CRUSHED ME

19 UGGLA BAVG KILLER

20 DREW BAD START

21 LIDGE FROM PERFECT TO SUCK'S

22 TULO NOT MUCH

23 J BRUCE LOW BAVG NOT THIS SEASON

24 ATKINS HORRIBLE 2ND HALF NUMBER'S LAST YEAR

25 PERALTA NO POWER Unfortunately, I have 4 from this list. I have to hope that:



1. Jose Reyes-has quality 2nd half: .290+, 7 hrs, 30+ sbs, 30 rbis, 50 rs.

8. Aramis Ramirez--has quality 2nd half: .285, 15+hrs, 60 rbis, 60 rs.

19. Dan Uggla--continue on his power pace, but get avg up to.260

23. Jay Bruce--continue with power pace, and get avg up to about .280.



Other notable disappointments:

Chien Ming-Wang, hopefully he is about to turn the corner.

Derrek Lee, coming on the last couple of weeks, hopefully the neck injury heals.

Cameron Maybin, not his year, I jumped the gun on him too early.

Originally posted by Edwards Kings:

I've got three from your list Eddie. Who has got more? I've got three...



Reyes, Bruce, Liriano...to go with Rickie Weeks and Ryan Doumit!

I also have three from the list of 25 on my ugly main event team (Ortiz, Vlad, and Soto).



Another nominee for disappointing players: Chris Young, the outfielder.



Kevin

No Alice Rios?

I'm sure Alexei Ramirez owners are happy to see his name not on the list - b/c he surely towards the top of that list April & most of May during the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Originally posted by eddiejag:

TOP 25 BUM'S

21 LIDGE FROM PERFECT TO SUCK'SLidge just placed on the 15 Day DL! YeeeHawwww!



Madson appears heir apparent.

The topic is "Who is the Bust of the Year".



No pictures from Q.



My disappointment runs deep

you want a bust Doughie ??? Well your movie Terminator Doughboy : I'll be Baked sucked

Originally posted by Quahogs:





you want a bust Doughie ??? Well your movie Terminator Doughboy : I'll be Baked sucked Thats' More Like it!!!

Terminator Salivation

Originally posted by DOUGHBOYS:

Terminator Salivation A bust thread doughie is just too obvious for a booby drop. I need a less obvious segue

Found one !

Originally posted by Quahogs:

Found one !



Sometimes I think that you employ a photographer just to create these on the spot. Nice work.

Emory, my photog Joe









got a picture of you looking bored !

YES Alexie Rameriz has come on as late so doesnt make the list and Rios is still on pace for 20 homers and 20 steals and feel the best is yet to come.