NFBC Message Boards

I usually don't ask for feedback, but sometimes feedback is good... From the 12 hole last night; my thoughts; light on power...and is Kaz OK....





Final Roster

Pos Name Team Pick

C Ramon Hernandez BAL R16 P4 Comment

C John Buck KC R22 P4 Comment

1B Prince Fielder MIL R1 P12 Comment

1B Joey Votto CIN R15 P12 Comment

1B Daric Barton OAK R24 P4 Comment

2B Howie Kendrick ANA R10 P4 Comment

2B Placido Polanco DET R13 P12 Comment

2B Matt Antonelli SD R28 P4 Comment

SS Troy Tulowitzki COL R3 P12 Comment

3B Chone Figgins ANA R4 P4 Comment

3B Jose Bautista PIT R27 P12 Comment

OF Grady Sizemore CLE R2 P4 Comment

OF Jason Bay PIT R8 P4 Comment

OF Johnny Damon NYY R9 P12 Comment

OF Lastings Milledge WAS R17 P12 Comment

OF Matt Diaz ATL R20 P4 Comment

SP Scott Kazmir TB R6 P4 Comment

SP Carlos Zambrano CHC R7 P12 Comment

SP Jeff Francis COL R11 P12 Comment

SP Oliver Perez NYM R12 P4 Comment

SP Hiroki Kuroda LA R19 P12 Comment

SP David Bush MIL R21 P12 Comment

SP Jason Bergmann WAS R23 P12 Comment

SP Jon Lieber CHC R25 P12 Comment

SP Chris Carpenter STL R29 P12 Comment

RP Jonathan Papelbon BOS R5 P12 Comment

RP Brad Lidge PHI R14 P4 Comment

RP Todd Jones DET R18 P4 Comment

RP Fernando RodneyDET R26 P4 Comment

RP David PriceTB R30 P4 Comment

I see a lot of people taking Carpenter- Is there info that you guys know? Tommy John surgery is usually a 16 -18 month rehab which makes it doubtful that he pitches in 2008. What am I missing?



Lunatic: Closesr stayed around long- Nice pick up on Lidge in 14. He says he will be ready by opening day.



You are not so far off in power that you can't fix during the season.

I think your offense is actually very good. If you get 40 homers from your catchers (may be a little on the high side but definitely possible)you should be decent in the power department. I really like your 3/4/5 starters that fall in behind your top 2 but im not crazy about the top 2. If Kazmir and Zambrano perform up to your expectations I definitely see this team at or near the top.

LUNATIC, Placido Polanco will take you to the promised land as he is the only one on your roster that matches my roster from last year.



Signed, 2007 SACK Satellite League Champion

I see some nice value picks.

First i noticed Barton , 24 round pick 4.

In the draft central report with the 11 leagues his adp was the 1st pick in round 22.Thats a 33 difference.

Howie Kendrick , round 10 pick 4.

Mock draft central 8th round pick 7.

Thats a 33 difference.

Brad Lidge 14 round pick 4.

MDC 11TH ROUND PICK 11.

THATS A 52 difference

Polanco 13th round pick 12

MDC 12th round pick 8.

difference 19

Their is more Damon Kuroda .

Good job on the value meter.

Eddie Nice observation. What you may not know however is Lunatic has done 127 mock drafts taking those guys earlier, with the sole motivation of knowing you would notice his value shopping prowess.

I have only done about 50 mocks...