Tell me what you think about this mock

Bobby J · Post by **Bobby J** » Sat Jan 19, 2008 10:25 am

I do not like the team very much but it projected out very well

1 - Soriano

2 - Tex

3 - Abreu

4 - Papelbon

5 - Kazmir

6 - Tejada

7 - Shields

8 - Gallardo

9 - Capps

10 - Encarnacion

11 - Pedroia

12 - Francis

13 - Lugo

14 - Wigginton

15 - Crisp

16 - Greinke

17 - Votto

18 - Nady

19 - Ankiel

20 - Bard

21 - Napoli

22 - Owings

23 - Villanueva

I picked from the 12 spot

eddiejag · Post by **eddiejag** » Sat Jan 19, 2008 1:38 pm

Overall i like this team , can use some breaks like crisp[playing time]Ankiel [playing time]

Staters b+

Bullpen A-

Speed b-

Power c+

Catching C-

pICKS I LIKE Tex a great 2nd round pick.

Wiggy and Greinke like both where you drafted them.

Gallardo nice.

Dont like Soraino at pick 12th would have taken someone else.

Crisp needs to leave boston or 4th of.

Pedroia kind of high.

Tejada a lot on his mind, brother gone.

Still overall a solid B.

Thunder · Post by **Thunder** » Sat Jan 19, 2008 2:17 pm

good or bad,,,right or wrong,,,lots of YOUNG pitching. i like the soriano pick at 12. i like teix, but not sure about him at 2.4. plus, are you covered in the SB cat?

Bobby J · Post by **Bobby J** » Sat Jan 19, 2008 3:54 pm

roughly 130 to 140, not the best but no where near the worst, projected out to 10 points

Batting 10

runs 9.5

hr 12

rbi 12

sb 10

wins 13

sv 10

k 15

whip 11

era 8

total 110.5

Raskol · Post by **Raskol** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 10:00 am

Here is my roster from the same draft, from pick 11. Thoughts?

1B Carlos Delgado NYM R9 P11

1B Ryan Garko CLE R14 P5

1B Richie Sexson SEA R17 P11

2B Chase Utley PHI R1 P11

2B Aaron Hill TOR R11 P11

3B Josh Fields CHW R10 P5

SS Troy Tulowitzki COL R3 P11

C Brian McCann ATL R4 P5

C Kurt Suzuki OAK R19 P11

OF Shane Victorino PHI R6 P5

OF Johnny Damon NYY R7 P11

OF Nate McLouth PIT R15 P11

OF Cameron Maybin FLA R16 P5

OF David DeJesus KC R20 P5

SP Johan Santana MIN R2 P5

SP Rich Hill CHC R8 P5

SP Curt Schilling BOS R13 P11

SP Andy Pettitte NYY R18 P5

SP Wandy Rodriguez HOU R21 P11

SP Andy Sonnanstine TB R22 P5

SP Kevin Millwood TEX R23 P11

RP Joe Nathan MIN R5 P11

RP Kevin Gregg FLA R12 P5

billywaz · Post by **billywaz** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 11:00 am

Originally posted by Raskolnikov:

Here is my roster from the same draft, from pick 11. Thoughts?

1B Carlos Delgado NYM R9 P11

1B Ryan Garko CLE R14 P5

1B Richie Sexson SEA R17 P11

2B Chase Utley PHI R1 P11

2B Aaron Hill TOR R11 P11

3B Josh Fields CHW R10 P5

SS Troy Tulowitzki COL R3 P11

C Brian McCann ATL R4 P5

C Kurt Suzuki OAK R19 P11

OF Shane Victorino PHI R6 P5

OF Johnny Damon NYY R7 P11

OF Nate McLouth PIT R15 P11

OF Cameron Maybin FLA R16 P5

OF David DeJesus KC R20 P5

SP Johan Santana MIN R2 P5

SP Rich Hill CHC R8 P5

SP Curt Schilling BOS R13 P11

SP Andy Pettitte NYY R18 P5

SP Wandy Rodriguez HOU R21 P11

SP Andy Sonnanstine TB R22 P5

SP Kevin Millwood TEX R23 P11

RP Joe Nathan MIN R5 P11

RP Kevin Gregg FLA R12 P5 I'm just learning this game that is played on the diamond (fantasy wise), but I think you are really going to hurting in the power department.

Santana could carry your pitching, but if he goes down, it could be scary from there IMO.

Again, I don't know much so don't take what I say very seriously.

Gordon Gekko · Post by **Gordon Gekko** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 12:04 pm

The more I see santana get pushed down to the 2nd round, the more I like the end of the draft. hmmm...

sportsbettingman · Post by **sportsbettingman** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 12:30 pm

Originally posted by Gordon Gekko:

The more I see santana get pushed down to the 2nd round, the more I like the end of the draft. hmmm... With a drop in every category from 2006 to 2007...and possibly going from the AL Central to the AL East...I don't see anything having an easy road to improvement except for Wins.

~Lance

Gordon Gekko · Post by **Gordon Gekko** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 12:40 pm

Lance - give me santana in the 2nd, and I'll be locking up another league title. Book it.

Captain Hook · Post by **Captain Hook** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 12:42 pm

GG don't you have work to do in other threads....

However I do agree with you - what a sweet start to a draft this year - picking up Johan at 2-3 or 2-4 yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

Gordon Gekko · Post by **Gordon Gekko** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 12:49 pm

Originally posted by Captain Hook:

GG don't you have work to do in other threads....

However I do agree with you - what a sweet start to a draft this year - picking up Johan at 2-3 or 2-4 yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

i'm multi-tasking

Raskol · Post by **Raskol** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 4:21 pm

I see power being pretty good. AVG however will be bad, and there are obviously some holes, which maybe the next 7 rounds would've sealed somehow.

I was amazed to see Utley at 1-11 and Johan at 2-5. From there, I thought it was pretty simple.

Captain Hook · Post by **Captain Hook** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 4:44 pm

Originally posted by Raskolnikov:

I see power being pretty good. AVG however will be bad, and there are obviously some holes, which maybe the next 7 rounds would've sealed somehow.

I was amazed to see Utley at 1-11 and Johan at 2-5. From there, I thought it was pretty simple. From the gifts at rounds 1 & 2, you needed to build on that - looks like to much reliance on position scarcity to me........

Pollcat Marv · Post by **Pollcat Marv** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 5:14 pm

I posted a mock about 10 days ago and got great feedback from the experts - so I'm here to try again until I get it right (or at least righter). Please provide your comments - I sucked last year and want to improve...

R1P7 Utley

R2P9 Berkman

R3P7 Abreu

R4P9 C Guillen (1B)

R5P7 Zimmerman

R6P9 C Young (P)

R7P7 Cain

R8P9 R Soriano

R9P7 Lincecum

R10P9 Saltalamacchia

R11P7 J Peralta (SS)

R12P9 Fukudome

R13P7 Reynolds (CN)

R14P9 B Wilson (RP)

R15P7 A Hill (MI)

R16P9 Harden

R17P7 Maybin

R18P9 Buck

R19P7 Buehrle

R20P9 Pie

R21P7 Shawn Hill

R22P9 Baez

R23P7 Winn

Edwards Kings · Post by **Edwards Kings** » Tue Jan 22, 2008 12:22 am

Originally posted by Pollcat Marv:

I posted a mock about 10 days ago and got great feedback from the experts - so I'm here to try again until I get it right (or at least righter). Please provide your comments - I sucked last year and want to improve...

R1P7 Utley

R2P9 Berkman

R3P7 Abreu

R4P9 C Guillen (1B)

R5P7 Zimmerman

R6P9 C Young (P)

R7P7 Cain

R8P9 R Soriano

R9P7 Lincecum

R10P9 Saltalamacchia

R11P7 J Peralta (SS)

R12P9 Fukudome

R13P7 Reynolds (CN)

R14P9 B Wilson (RP)

R15P7 A Hill (MI)

R16P9 Harden

R17P7 Maybin

R18P9 Buck

R19P7 Buehrle

R20P9 Pie

R21P7 Shawn Hill

R22P9 Baez

R23P7 Winn Hmmmmm...I was wondering Marv, 1B appears to me to be a pretty deep position so was there a run on CM? I was looking at you using Guillen (who is a nice value by the way at 4/9)at 1B. SS is decidely thinner after the top three, so I was thinking you might be able to find a CM (or OF for that matter as Berkman also qualifies at 1B) that could outpoint Peralta. IMHO, Utley/Guillen/Hill is much stronger than Utley/Peralta/Hill. What other 1B (or OF) was available in the 11th? Just thoughts.

Pollcat Marv · Post by **Pollcat Marv** » Tue Jan 22, 2008 2:41 am

Wayne,

Thanks for your thoughts. There was a run on CM - hence, my draft of Reynolds a couple of rounds earlier than I would have liked. OF was thin too, as evidenced by an unknown quantity like Fukudome being the best option in the next round.

By the way, is there any way to say "Fukudome" without having my mom return from the grave to wash my mouth out with soap?

Edwards Kings · Post by **Edwards Kings** » Tue Jan 22, 2008 4:17 am

Try "...but MOM, all my friends are saying it!"

Captain Hook · Post by **Captain Hook** » Tue Jan 22, 2008 5:45 am

Originally posted by Pollcat Marv:

Wayne,

Thanks for your thoughts. There was a run on CM - hence, my draft of Reynolds a couple of rounds earlier than I would have liked. OF was thin too, as evidenced by an unknown quantity like Fukudome being the best option in the next round.

By the way, is there any way to say "Fukudome" without having my mom return from the grave to wash my mouth out with soap? Fook-uh-doh-may

Dub · Post by **Dub** » Sat Feb 02, 2008 5:03 am

1 - Soriano- I like this pick- 9th? Upside is excellent. You can get Hanley type numbers from many spots lower in the round.(but he is a dog in real life)

2 - Tex- Solid, little risk 2nd pick- NICE.

Team looking good in all OF categoires so far

3 - Abreu- Aonther good pick. Lots of upside- in a good year he can be a 1st rounder due to the power/speed combo

4 - Papelbon- First pitcher and best closer in the game.

5 - Kazmir- Very nice anchor

6 - Tejada- Not what he once was, but this is the 6th round and again there is upside. Nice value pick.

7 - Shields- Under rated and could be break out pitcher of the year in the AL

8 - Gallardo- NOT under rated and could be break out pitcher of the year in the NL

9 - Capps- 2nd closer - Pen looks Solid

10 - Encarnacion- great power upside in a GOOD lineup.

11 - Pedroia- Nice 2b at this spot. He wont hurt you.

12 - Francis- Up and down at best.

13 - Lugo- great speed pick and upside on BA. Nice Pick!!

14 - Wigginton- Im not a believer, but so far he has been a quality major league ball player

15 - Crisp- Does he play?

16 - Greinke- Sleeper? is this the year and a good answer to the week #3 Gekko question.

17 - Votto -Great propspect- I hate Dusty.

18 - Nady- Can you time his streaks?

19 - Ankiel- Great story tainted by roid allegeations

20 - Bard. Platoon

21 - Napoli- popular sleeper pick

22 - Owings- Flyer could pay off. On a good team.

23 - Villanueva- Who?

This team has a real good shot- But 60% of this game is luck.

Dub · Post by **Dub** » Sat Feb 02, 2008 5:31 am

R1P7 Utley- David Wright type numbers from 2nd base (maybe be better)

R2P9 Berkman- Awesome when he is right and multi positional

R3P7 Abreu- Ditto what I said on the last Mock

R4P9 C Guillen (1B)- Another Multi positional guy who is a stand out player when not on the disabled list

R5P7 Zimmerman- Can be a stand out player

R6P9 C Young (P)- real good, but is he really an Ace? I rather have the OFer

R7P7 Cain- Great talent on a bad team

R8P9 R Soriano- he throw Beebees

R9P7 Lincecum- Most talented of all. What are the odds in Vegas on the Giants? They can't score but they have some potentially dominating pitching!!

R10P9 Saltalamacchia- A lot to prove. can he walk the walk?

R11P7 J Peralta (SS)- Popular bust pick

R12P9 Fukudome- Who knows? I can't figure out the imports from Asia

R13P7 Reynolds (CN) Mark? You needed the position

R14P9 B Wilson (RP)- Closer?

R15P7 A Hill (MI)- Love this pick in this spot

R16P9 Harden- health always and issue

R17P7 Maybin- Blue chip prospect. Marlins always have a few.

R18P9 Buck- Hard nose player

R19P7 Buehrle- High upside in round 19

R20P9 Pie- wild card, another Dusty issue

R21P7 Shawn Hill- he's good, Big park- nice wire pick up last year, but not even close to being the best Hill

R22P9 Baez- Closer?

This team also has a shot at a prize

Chest Rockwell · Post by **Chest Rockwell** » Sat Feb 02, 2008 5:44 am

R20P9 Pie- wild card, another Dusty issue

R21P7 Shawn Hill- he's good, Big park- nice wire pick up last year, but not even close to being the best Hill

R22P9 Baez- Closer?

This team also has a shot at a prize [/QB][/quote]

Who am I to disagree with a guy this accomplished in his yahoo league.

Pie- I was unaware Dusty Baker still managed the Cubs

Hill- silly me I thought the Nats were moving out of RFK this year

Baez- I once again was confused and thought Baez was out for the year with an injury.

Much more solid effort than the last time Marv- I think you took R Soriano a little early he is trending about 2 rounds later but he is a guy you have to like if he can stay healthy.

[ February 02, 2008, 11:45 AM: Message edited by: Chest Rockwell ]

Dub · Post by **Dub** » Sat Feb 02, 2008 7:21 am

Originally posted by Chest Rockwell:

R20P9 Pie- wild card, another Dusty issue

R21P7 Shawn Hill- he's good, Big park- nice wire pick up last year, but not even close to being the best Hill

R22P9 Baez- Closer?

This team also has a shot at a prize Who am I to disagree with a guy this accomplished in his yahoo league.

Pie- I was unaware Dusty Baker still managed the Cubs

Hill- silly me I thought the Nats were moving out of RFK this year

Baez- I once again was confused and thought Baez was out for the year with an injury.

Much more solid effort than the last time Marv- I think you took R Soriano a little early he is trending about 2 rounds later but he is a guy you have to like if he can stay healthy. [/QB][/quote]

Thanks Chester in any case I got the sentiment right on all three. You must award some points on style and I did it quick. Not one positive thing to say about?

I concede that you are the "Lord of Fantasy Baseball".

Ancient Jewish proverb: You should only be so successful in life.

Nice first name-Kent. [heard like Seinfield addressing Newman]

King of Queens · Post by **King of Queens** » Sat Feb 02, 2008 7:33 am

Dub, haven't you learned yet? In February, we are ALL "lords of fantasy baseball."

As for you, Mr. Rockwell, remember: you could argue that Danys Baez is out for the year, but you'd be right.

Chest Rockwell · Post by **Chest Rockwell** » Sat Feb 02, 2008 7:43 am

Originally posted by King of Queens:

Dub, haven't you learned yet? In February, we are ALL "lords of fantasy baseball."

As for you, Mr. Rockwell, remember: you could argue that Danys Baez is out for the year, but you'd be right. Glenn you crack me up-

Chest Rockwell · Post by **Chest Rockwell** » Sat Feb 02, 2008 7:47 am

Originally posted by Dub:

quote:Originally posted by Chest Rockwell:

R20P9 Pie- wild card, another Dusty issue

R21P7 Shawn Hill- he's good, Big park- nice wire pick up last year, but not even close to being the best Hill

R22P9 Baez- Closer?

This team also has a shot at a prize Who am I to disagree with a guy this accomplished in his yahoo league.

Pie- I was unaware Dusty Baker still managed the Cubs

Hill- silly me I thought the Nats were moving out of RFK this year

Baez- I once again was confused and thought Baez was out for the year with an injury.

Much more solid effort than the last time Marv- I think you took R Soriano a little early he is trending about 2 rounds later but he is a guy you have to like if he can stay healthy. [/QUOTE]Thanks Chester in any case I got the sentiment right on all three. You must award some points on style and I did it quick. Not one positive thing to say about?

I concede that you are the "Lord of Fantasy Baseball".

Ancient Jewish proverb: You should only be so successful in life.

Nice first name-Kent. [heard like Seinfield addressing Newman] [/QB][/quote]

a Seinfelf fan just when I thought all was lost with my new friend dub. You my friend are an antichestite. You remind me a lot of Lloyd Braun.

My friends call me kent you should just address me as Mr Rockwell.

On a more serious note you may want to save your money if you do not know who the manager of the Cubs is, where the Nats play, or what pitchers are out for the year.. Just a little advice between us girls.