I'll weigh in my thoughts now, too.
Rollins after the phenominal year is a bit overrated in my opinion (would I like him on my team...yes). It would kill me to pass by those SB's, but I would probably pass him by. I do not think he will be there at 7, though.
Utley is nothing short of great, but gets an extra kick for position scarcity. I am not sure I buy that this year (kind of a position I have taken on further review of the other positions). I could take him and smile, but there are two other players who will be offensive juggernaughts this year, so I would probably pass on Utley (we will see if I eat my words on Saturday under pressure

).
The difference in my opinion between Holliday and Cabrera is slim if any difference exists at all. Cabrera will be a BA machine (as opposed to Holliday's mere .315 to .320). Holliday will toss in 10+ more SB than Cabrera.
All else being equal, of the four, I am leaning towards Holliday as I do not think OF is as deep as it has been and the middle of the pack in all the other positions is a bit deeper to me this year.
Fun talk. None of the four is a mistake. Sort of like when you ask me if I prefer blondes, brunettes, raven-haired, or red-headed. The answer will inevitable be "Yes"!
Baseball is a slow, boring, complex, cerebral game that doesn't lend itself to histrionics. You 'take in' a baseball game, something odd to say about a football or basketball game, with the clock running and the bodies flying.
Charles Krauthammer