Shields or Garza?

[Steel Lugnuts]

Any opinion on which one you'd rather have moving forward? Garza's looked pretty good but Shields is on a better team and should end up with more wins...although, Garza may get traded to a contender before the trade deadline.

[Bronx Yankees]

I like Shields better. Garza may get more Ks, but I think Shields is the better pitcher. He also will get more wins, although that's not Garza's fault. Of course, Garza looked pretty good yesterday ....

[KJ Duke]

Shields is more volatile and has the tougher schedule. I'd take Garza and expect better ratios with comparable Ks and Ws.