A(djustable) J(ustification) Pollock

Post Reply
DOUGHBOYS
Posts: 13091
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2005 6:00 pm

A(djustable) J(ustification) Pollock

Post by DOUGHBOYS » Tue Sep 27, 2016 10:05 am

I'm studying for the PreMature. There are a myriad of players that I don't know how to place.
Is Brian Dozier a power hitter?
He is this year. But, what about next? What can we expect from Dozier?
I already know what columnists and projectionist will do with Dozier.
They will put his power numbers between what he did this year and what he has done in the past. They play it safe that way.
Which makes me wonder what good a columnist or projectionist is.
Aren't they supposed to tell us that Dozier was in for a power year?
We believe them to be proactionary, they're reactionary.

That's what I love about the PreMature. There is very little written about who will do what in next year's fantasy baseball world.
We are the Lewis And Clark of drafts.
Blazing a trail that will be followed by millions of others.
Blah Blah Blah.
Geez Kenyon, shuddup!
I didn't write this to minimize projectionists or maximize the meaning of the PreMature, so let's get to the subject at hand...

AJ Pollock.
What the Hell do we do with AJ Pollock?
Like Dozier, we already know that projectionists will put him between his career year and his injury years.
A given.
Pollock is a fantasy difference maker.
He's also a Ming Vase.
Expensive and so brittle.
Unlike that Ming Vase, Pollock has to move to prove his worth. And when Pollock moves, the chances of him and injury multiply.
Pollock is a wonderful player. A six tool player. His best tool, being disabled.

So again, what do we do with Pollock?
Last year, he was taken at the bottom of the first round or near the top of the second round in most drafts.
I felt that was too high of a price to pay for a player with his injury history. In Pollock's Major League career, he has played over 100 games twice in his five years.
In the Minors, he missed a whole year as well.
Pollock is great at playing baseball. He's just better at getting hurt playing baseball.
If somebody wants to take a chance on him in the first or second round, he is their player. Especially in a draft where Pollock will have dozens of chances to get hurt, even before spring training.

Third round?
I think, realistically, somebody pulls the trigger in this round. It won't be me. But there are some gamblers in our league who will take the chance on a difference making player.
For me, depending on my roster, I would start considering Pollock in the fourth round. But more than likely pass on him in most instances.
He is one of those players that we want to see make it out of Spring Training, injury-free, before drafting him.
Last year, he did not and many suffered the consequences.
For those that drafted him before his injury, the 'AJ' in Pollocks name meant 'Already Jacked'.
In the PreMature, stability is a good quality.
Pollock's sixth tool is his propensity for getting hurt.
A guy like Mike Trout's sixth tool would be his stability.
Fantasy-wise, Pollock is as stable as Yasiel Puig at a frat party.

There is one more thing that bugs me about Pollock.
He has produced just one year.
One year.
In his eight years of professional baseball, Pollock has hit double digit home runs, one time.
His career year of 2015.
He has never driven in more than 80 runs.
Even in his career year, he drove in just 76.
He stole 39 bases in his career year. He came close to that figure once in the minors with 36.
Will he run as much?
Injuries have a way of slowing down base stealers.
Maybe the better question would be, do we WANT him to run as much?
Running and sliding increases his chances of being hurt.
Ok, I just talked myself out of Pollock for even the fourth round :D

Our draft starts Friday. I'll let you know where Pollock goes when drafted.
On my tombstone-
Wait! I never had the perfect draft!

headhunters
Posts: 1976
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 6:00 pm

Re: A(djustable) J(ustification) Pollock

Post by headhunters » Tue Sep 27, 2016 11:10 am

just crossed aj off my list of possible 3rd round picks. have you taking him round 3. if i have time i will compile your draft by reading who you have slammed this month. dozier looks like another round 2 or 3 pick. ps- amazing a teams era can move .5 point this late in the year- but when colon and roark are your guys- i guess it can happen.

DOUGHBOYS
Posts: 13091
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2005 6:00 pm

Re: A(djustable) J(ustification) Pollock

Post by DOUGHBOYS » Tue Sep 27, 2016 11:53 am

headhunters wrote:just crossed aj off my list of possible 3rd round picks. have you taking him round 3. if i have time i will compile your draft by reading who you have slammed this month. dozier looks like another round 2 or 3 pick. ps- amazing a teams era can move .5 point this late in the year- but when colon and roark are your guys- i guess it can happen.
I do actually like what Dozier and Pollock can bring to the table.
But somebody is going to want/like them more than me.
Odds for me in drafting either would be well above 15-1.
Mike, if you think that I 'slam and draft', I'd have Joey Votto and Brandon Belt on every team.
Haven't taken neither in five years or more.
Man, if Belt ever gets traded to a ball park that is hitter friendly though,...... KATIE BAR THE DOOR!

Going back to the 15-1 odds....
That is the odds (kinda) that we have in getting each player.
If having 10 teams already drafted by March and we drafted the same player on eight of them, it means we love that player.
We decreased the odds by taking him when available or even overdrafting him.
I love the PreMature in that it is almost impossible to overdraft a player since there's no adp.
On my tombstone-
Wait! I never had the perfect draft!

headhunters
Posts: 1976
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 6:00 pm

Re: A(djustable) J(ustification) Pollock

Post by headhunters » Wed Sep 28, 2016 9:07 am

dan- times are slow- just having a little fun. i am actually thinking of drafting votto- never have but down at 11- 15 things seem really murky. i think the path you want to take may really over ride the projected value of the player. of course last year i really didn't like my draft that much and loved dave's- so what do i know.

Post Reply